There’s no question that the winners of ABC’s Boy Band are a match made in musical heaven, and when it comes to their relationships off stage, In Real Life shows that bromances have no bounds. Brady, Chance, Sergio, Drew and Michael have quickly become a family, and when we caught up with the guys of In Real Life at their L.A. home, and they shared the details of what life has been like since that fateful night that they officially became a band.

After dazzling the world with radio and television appearances, meeting their adoring fans and debuting their first single on the mega screens of Times Square in New York, In Real Life shares what’s it’s like to be catapulted into the spotlight. And they even gave us the scoop on their newly released Christmas singles, because it’s never too soon to start getting in the holiday spirit, right?

We’re not ashamed to admit that we’re crushing on this band in a major way. Find out why by checking out the exclusive acoustic performance of “Eyes Closed” below, which promises to make your heart swoon. And catch our full interview above with the guys as they dish on the ups and downs of being the newest boy band on the block!