First dates can be a bit…well…tricky. On top of the potential for first date jitters, you have to figure out the right outfit to wear. Do you keep it cool and casual, or should you dress to impress? You want to look like you’re making an effort, but not trying too hard. You want to look nice, but not too nice. Cool, but not too cool. Decisions, decisions! What’s a girl to do?

Recently we sat down with some of our favorite MTV stars, and we put the question to them! What IS the perfect first date outfit? Hear from Gregg Sulkin – who’s going strong with our former cover girl Bella Thorne, Katie Stevens – in a serious relationship with music writer and producer Paul DiGiovanni, and more MTV stars. They have great ideas for every scenario, and you can choose the one that best fits your personality!