Season 1 of Guilty Party may be over, but we’re already daydreaming about what drama a possible Season 2 could hold. In case you missed it, AT&T  and Hello Lab’s collab Guilty Party is an online interactive series that lets the audience participate in the storyline. As mysteries unfold via clues posted on the show’s social channels, the characters interact directly with fans in the comments section of each episode and on the show’s vlogs on YouTube. The show features influencers like Teala Dunn, Miles McKenna, Tiffany Alvord, Jessie Paege, Kian Lawley, Alexis G. Zall and Manolo Gonzalez Vergara, to name a few, and it’s definitely been the addictive hit of the new school year.

We caught up with the cast at a recent interactive fan event held at the one and only Warren Academy, and we got the cast’s thoughts on possible new drama that would be perfect in a second season of this online hit. Although a new season hasn’t been confirmed, there are so many storylines that we’d love to see continue. Hear what the cast has to say about their time filming Season 1 in the video above, and check out our on set experience alongside fans and the stars of Guilty Party  in our interviews below!