We’re obsessed with all things Shadowhunters, so when we had the opportunity to chat with some of the cast members, we were excited to get the inside scoop! Watch as Katherine McNamara (Clary), Emeraude Toubia (Isabelle), Harry Shum, Jr. (Magnus) and Isaiah Mustafa (Luke) play our “Most Likely To…” game and give their castmates superlatives, including Most Likely to Dominate Karaoke, Biggest Flirt and Most Likely to Be Late on Set. What awards would you give your favorite members of the Shadowhunters cast?

Be sure to tune into the latest episode of Shadowhunters, Tuesdays at 9/8c on FreeForm!