Most beauty trends come and go, but some are so life-changing for your look that they stick around for the long haul. Bold lips. A winged eyeliner. The perfect highlight. Statement-making faux freckles. There are so many trends to try, but which ones have true staying power?

We caught up with some of our favorite beauty gurus at Beautycon LA to see which trends they’re loving, and which ones they’re ready to leave behind. For the most part, beauty YouTubers and celebs alike are ready to say goodbye to some of 2017’s top makeup trends. See if you agree with their top picks and no-go looks in the video above!