Maybe it’s just great acting, but have you ever found yourself bingeing a show and wondering how the main girl and guy can make fake romance look so convincing? It has to be coming from some real feelings, right? To make matters even more frustrating, how about the celebs who claim to be best friends off-camera? Come on, guys, just date already! Here are the 5 top favorite on-screen couples who have us fooled into thinking they’re perfect for each other.

Dove Cameron and Garrett Clayton

Okay, so we’e aware that these two weren’t the real-deal on-screen couple in Hairspray Live! When it comes to Link Larkin’s leading lady, we’re definitely #TeamTracy and thumbs down for Amber. However, Justine fave Dove Cameron is super close with her costar Garrett Clayton. These two even take tons of selfies together, hang with each other on weekends and pose side-by-side on the red carpet. Our only question is, why are they not dating?

Lucy Hale and Ian Harding

Don’t even get us started on these two. This on-screen Pretty Little Liars couple are off-screen besties. They’ve been notorious for goofing around and pranking each other on set since season 1 of the show. That means there’s been a lot of silliness, because Aria and Ezra are the only PLL couple that has stood the test of time in Rosewood. Plus, they always take the time to give back by volunteering and supporting causes together. Why, why, why are they not a real-life couple?

Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling

If you weren’t convinced that Emma and Ryan should have turned their on-screen chemistry into an off-screen romance after Crazy, Stupid, Love, then maybe their performance in La La Land will change your mind. These two are just one of those pairs who vibe so well that they keep getting cast opposite each other. You can’t help but fall in love with them as they fall for each other! Come on, guys, please date in real life. It’ll be fun…we promise.

Leighton Meester and Ed Westwick

We think every Gossip Girl addict would agree with us when we say that Chuck and Blair need to have a happily ever after in reality. These two were electric on the show! No one else held a candle to them, not even Dan and Serena. Can you two just say those three little words to each other IRL? K? K.

Shailene Woodley and Ansel Elgort

Though they claim to be just friends, we’re still hoping that this pair can find a way to fall in love. Yes, they may have played brother and sister in Divergent, but don’t forget how they made us swoon and cry in The Fault in Our Stars. Remember the scene where he tells her he’s taking her to Amsterdam? Talk about #relationshipgoals. Long live Gus and Hazel!